Asked by SelinaEnglish 🇬🇧

Why is a raven like a writing desk?

Profile picture


Verified tutor tick

Louise Creechan

PhD researcher and tutor in English Literature at the University of Glasgow.

Good one...but Carroll did answer his ‘unanswerable riddle’. Apparently, "Because it can produce a few notes, tho they are very flat; and it is never put with the wrong end in front!". Carroll originally spelt never with an a - ‘nevar’ - but his publisher corrected him so it no longer spelt ‘raven’ backwards. Hilarious...

Profile picture

Felicia Jones

I am an experienced tutor, having taught over 25 students, ranging from ages 11-18 in a number of subjects.

All things considered, actually this puzzle has numerous answers. Individuals have had a considerable measure of time to brainstorm something cunning. It previously showed up in Alice\'s Experiences in Wonderland, a broadly unpleasant children\'s book which Lewis Carroll wrote in 1865. Alice nods off one day, pursues a white rabbit down a rabbit gap, and winds up in a universe of insane rationale which Carroll dependent on what he considered the strange rationale that was heaped up in his picked field of science. Apparently, the craziest characters are the Frantic Hatter and the Walk Rabbit. Alice winds up at a casual get-together with them, and the Frantic Hatter asks her the inquiry, "Why is a raven like a composition desk?\" Alice asks him for what reason, and he concedes he doesn\'t know. He was simply inquiring. Alice criticizes him with, \"I figure you may improve the time than squandering it in asking questions that have no answers.\" ha! Take that you upstart science punks! Land a position! The unanswered enigma, which numerous individuals were presented to in their developmental years, got under people\'s skin. In their endeavor to satisfactorily remove it, they\'ve thought of answers. A wonderful, however, meta, the answer is, \"Poe composed on both,\" given by riddle lover Sam Lloyd. More in the soul of the hogwash type, Aldous Huxley wandered, \"Because there is a \'b\' in both and a \'n\' in neither.\" Delightfully strange. The unanswerable question has been replied, however, and has been responded in due order regarding numerous years. Lewis Carroll himself composed the appropriate response, subsequent to being harassed by individuals relentless since the book\'s unique distribution. He said that, in the first book, there was no answer. To end the torment of interminable curious fan letters, however, he felt free to brainstormed a satisfactory reaction that he put in the prelude to later versions. Carroll\'s response to why a raven resembles a composition work area? \"Because it can deliver a couple of notes, tho they are level; and it is never put with the wrong end in front!\" I\'m beyond any doubt your thighs are presently sore from the continued slapping they took after you read that line. Initially, it should be somewhat more clever than that. Carroll spelled \'never,\' as \'nevar\' — \'raven\' spelled in reverse — yet an editor deleted the modified play on words before it was distributed. Carroll\'s answer was less mainstream than his inquiry. Individuals have held on in thinking of their own responses to the vigorously considered enigma. I\'ll take my own shot at it. "Why is a raven like a composition work area? Since nor is ever drawn nearer without caws." Eh? Eh??

Profile picture

Da Wa

6hak ndkabe t w

LEWIS CARROLL himself proposed an answer on it saying, ”Because it can produce a few notes, though they are very flat; and it is never put with the wrong end in front!"

Answers from these tutors

Asked in English 🇬🇧



What are some theories and principles of assessment and feedback in schools?

Assessments are tests that we are all familiar with as they allow teachers and students alike to communicate academic progress. Some forms of these ...



Context about An Inspector Calls? (1912?

It is an example of immediate post-war drama, it was written after World War Two. Post-war dramas take up some of the economic, political, and socia...



Who knows any techniques to memorize fast words in a new language?

Flashcards with the word in the new language on one side and translation on the other side.



How does Macbeth’s power change during the play?

Macbeth’s power starts off from an outside perspective as being contextually the epitome of an upper class male stereotype, young, mighty, loyal to ...



How is Romeo presented in Romeo and Juliet?

The presentation of Romeo varies throughout the course of the play. I will pick out 3 key ways he is presented with some analysis of a key quotation...



How do you write a perfect PEAL paragraph for gcse?

Please provide a sample question so that I may illustrate practical application and you can use this as a template. Nonetheless, this is something y...



How do I write a petal paragraph?

Hello! The best way to answer is to follow the letters. First of all, a Point. This is the main argument you will present in the paragraph. One sent...



How does golding present the darkness in mans heart. In lord of the Flies?

To “explore the darkness of man’s heart” is one of the key themes in William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies. As the boys on the island regress fr...



Could people give me a good detailed summery of Christmas Carol?

On Christmas Eve, Scrooge is visited by a series of ghosts, starting with his old business partner, Jacob Marley. The three spirits which follow, th...



What is the difference between How I should answer q2 paper 1 and q3 paper 2 in gcse aqa English language exam?

Both questions ask you analyse language techniques so in terms of thinking it may be similar answering them although paper one focuses on exploratio...

Find me a tutor

We take your privacy seriously. View our policy.