Asked by TasnimGeneral 🏛

Does Human Rights Act 1998 challenge parliamentary sovereignty?

Profile picture

VERIFIED

Verified tutor tick

Michael Comba

Oxford graduate and experienced tutor.

It certainly ‘challenges’ parliamentary sovereignty as it made primary legislation much more easy to challenge in Court. Anderson V Secretary of State for the Home Department and A and others v the Secretary of State for the Home Department are probably the two most high profile and controversial declarations of incompatibility levelled against primary legalisation. It also provided some indication that fundamental rights are not necessarily protected adequately by Parliament alone. This questions the British constitutional notion of Parliament as an all-knowing and all-powerful body, which underpins the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty. Arguably the HRA has also allowed an increase in the use of case law in establishing new legislation. Campbell v NGN Ltd arguably introduced a right to privacy which parliament had not legislated. However, the mechanisms of the HRA, declarations of incompatibility, to challenge Parliament are weak. Parliament can chose to ignore them. They did in Scott v Scott and Chester v the Secretary of State for Justice. Also, unlike other constitutional instruments elsewhere, the HRA can be repealed at any time by Parliament. Furthermore, the HRA has been more effective, and has much stronger mechanisms, against the Executive. Arguably, the Executive had seen a period of dominance before 1998 and the HRA has limited this, thereby strengthening the role of Parliament with this balancing. Overall, certainly a challenge, but quite a weak one.

Michael also answered

Asked in General 🏛

ASKED BY STELLA

GENERAL 🏛

What are the advantages and disadvantages of assessment in schools?

Advantages: - Can be used to determine progress of students. - Can be used to evaluate the effectiveness of teaching strategies. - Can be used to me...

ASKED BY LOTTIE

GENERAL 🏛

Could someone explain Standard Deviation? I am studying for the level three statistics award?

Standard deviation is a measure of spread. It gives a quantity expressing how much the members of a group differ from the mean value of a group. Thi...

ASKED BY SELINA

GENERAL 🏛

Is it possible to get into Oxford if I only have 7 GCSEs?

There are many other factors that okay into acceptance at Oxford such as your Personal statement, how well you do in the interview, your grades at A...

ASKED BY SOMERSBY

GENERAL 🏛

What are the differences and similarities between meiosis and Interphase?

Meiosis is a type of cell division that gives four “daughter” cells with half the number of chromosomes as the original “parent” cell. This is mainl...

ASKED BY ISABELLA

GENERAL 🏛

How do I solve quadratics by completing the squares? I’ve looked it up, but I don’t get it and I have homework due on it?

Best to give an example x^2 -6x +8=0 can factorise it easily but by completing the square you do this (x-3)^2 +8 -9 =0 so (x-3)^2 - 1= 0 So basicall...

ASKED BY EMILY

GENERAL 🏛

Any tips how to get over being squeamish/ fainting of blood?

With being squeamish sometimes exposure therapy is good for getting over negative feelings associated with something. For example you could watch vi...

ASKED BY ELOISE

GENERAL 🏛

Can someone help explain the process of electrolysis?

In chemistry and manufacturing, electrolysis is a technique that uses a direct electric current (DC) to drive an otherwise non-spontaneous chemical ...

ASKED BY JESS

GENERAL 🏛

What is the sociological view on the hidden curriculum?

Most sociologists use the term “hidden curriculum” to refer to the various characteristics of schooling that are unquestioned or 'taken for granted'...

ASKED BY JESS

GENERAL 🏛

What is the best way to revise so the information gets stuck in your head and you don’t forget it?

The best way to revise is to read out loud the entire piece of information that you need to learn and highlight the important parts with a highlight...

ASKED BY SSARAH

GENERAL 🏛

Please give me a tip how to write a review about bad restauran?

Hi Ssarah, Like any other idea, when we express our opinions it is important to present our view concisely (briefly and clearly) and explain the rea...

Find me a tutor

We take your privacy seriously. View our policy.