Asked by TasnimGeneral πŸ›

How is judicial review challenge Parliamentary Sovereignty in terms of Human Rights Act 1998?

Profile picture

VERIFIED

Verified tutor tick

Michael Comba

Oxford graduate and experienced tutor.

The basis of the British constitution is that parliament is sovereign - meaning parliament is the supreme law making body and no other body can amend or override parliament’s law making powers. The HRA 1998 introduced the European Convention on Human Rights into the British legal system. The court now has to determine actions made by the government (often by virtue of laws passed by parliament). If it believes these to be incompatible it may issue a β€œDeclaration of Incompatibility” - a non-binding declaration. Whilst there is no onus on parliament to affect these declarations, there are only a few examples of Parliament ignoring the court’s decisions. Prisoner voting rights remains the only notable example. Nonetheless, judicial review of legislation remains fairly uncommon in the U.K., meaning the HRA has had a fairly limited impact on parliamentary sovereignty. Indeed, arguably the HRA has in some areas enhanced parliamentary sovereignty. In Miller v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union, the Court held that Parliament had to approve withdrawing from the European Union, rather than the executive through prerogative powers.

Michael also answered

Asked in General πŸ›

ASKED BY SOPHIE

GENERAL πŸ›

What are unbalanced equations and how do you balance them?

Unbalanced equations usually appear in chemical equations - both sides have different number of chemical elements. Example Original equation: NaCl +...

ASKED BY LILY

GENERAL πŸ›

What can I do to get ahead for GCSEs? I’m really worried :?

- identify the subjects that you are less confident in - make a study plan - prioritise the knowledge in the syllabus and make sure you know them - ...

ASKED BY TASNIM

GENERAL πŸ›

What is judicial review and how does it challenge parliamentary sovereignty?

Judicial review refers to the process by which the actions of the legislative and executive branch can and are subjected to be viewed by the judicia...

ASKED BY JOSH

GENERAL πŸ›

How do I find the area of a triangle when I only know the three side lengths?

You need to know at least one angle otherwise it is impossible

ASKED BY TASNIM

GENERAL πŸ›

What is the difference between overreaching and overriding?

To override something is to place your response above another one as the priority. For example James decides the group would go and watch β€˜The Grinc...

ASKED BY AIMEE

GENERAL πŸ›

How is concrete made? a step by step list in detail?

There are three basic components of concrete Cement, Sand and Aggregate ( mixture of sand, gravel and crushed stones ). The grades of concrete are c...

ASKED BY TASNIM

GENERAL πŸ›

What is a resulting/applied and constructive trust and their differences?

There is significant overlap. Resulting trust arise in the absence of an express trust in which, say, an individual contributes towards the purchase...

ASKED BY BELLA

GENERAL πŸ›

How do I find the equation of a line on a graph using the equation y=mx+c?

The general form of a straight line equation is y = mx + c, where m is the gradient, c is the y-intercept and x and y are the coordinates of any giv...

ASKED BY PAULA

GENERAL πŸ›

What is the difference between transverse and a longitudinal wave?

Longitudinal Waves: A wave where displacement/oscillation (of particles) is parallel to the direction of energy transfer. a. Example: Sound waves Lo...

ASKED BY LEAH

GENERAL πŸ›

The arithmetic average if 10 numbers 2,-5,-2,5, x - 3, 10, is 8 find x?

We need all 10 numbers to do this

Find me a tutor

We take your privacy seriously. View our policy.