Get an answer in 5 minutes

We'll notify as soon as your question has been answered.

Plus iconAsk a question to our educators
HISTORY
Asked by Tasnim

Does Human Rights Act 1998 challenge parliamentary sovereignty?

It certainly ‘challenges’ parliamentary sovereignty as it made primary legislation much more easy to challenge in Court. Anderson V Secretary of State for the Home Department and A and others v the Secretary of State for the Home Department are probably the two most high profile and controversial declarations of incompatibility levelled against primary legalisation. It also provided some indication that fundamental rights are not necessarily protected adequately by Parliament alone. This questions the British constitutional notion of Parliament as an all-knowing and all-powerful body, which underpins the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty. Arguably the HRA has also allowed an increase in the use of case law in establishing new legislation. Campbell v NGN Ltd arguably introduced a right to privacy which parliament had not legislated. However, the mechanisms of the HRA, declarations of incompatibility, to challenge Parliament are weak. Parliament can chose to ignore them. They did in Scott v Scott and Chester v the Secretary of State for Justice. Also, unlike other constitutional instruments elsewhere, the HRA can be repealed at any time by Parliament. Furthermore, the HRA has been more effective, and has much stronger mechanisms, against the Executive. Arguably, the Executive had seen a period of dominance before 1998 and the HRA has limited this, thereby strengthening the role of Parliament with this balancing. Overall, certainly a challenge, but quite a weak one.

Michael's profile picture
Verified
Michael Comba
·

8.3k students helped

Similar History questions

What is Q&A on Scoodle?

At Scoodle we understand that everyone learns in a different way. Some people learn through practice, using essays and notes; others prefer video lessons to watch and learn, some just need help with a specifically hard question, while some learn best 1-on-1 tutoring sessions. At Scoodle we cater for all types of learning styles and needs. From GCSE Maths video lessons to A-level English essays and specialist educators in every subject - we’ve got you covered.

Faces of students on ScoodleFaces of students on ScoodleFaces of students on Scoodle
Scoodle has helped over 131,000 students so far

Need help with Secondary History?

Getting expert help from a tutor is a great way to improve your History grades.

Learn with Video Lessons
A-Level Physical Chemistry
1hr 9m · 7 videos
Ibrahim's profile picture
Ibrahim Dangra
·

1.9k students helped

A-Level Physical Chemistry
GCSE Maths - Numbers
1hr 28m · 8 videos
Paja's profile picture
Paja Kruzikova
·

689 students helped

GCSE Maths - Numbers
How to Analyse (Unseen) Poetry
20m · 7 videos
Nina's profile picture
Nina Modak
·

2k students helped

How to Analyse (Unseen) Poetry
COVID-19 Guidance For Students
30m · 5 videos
Jackie's profile picture
Jackie Jones
·

802 students helped

COVID-19 Guidance For Students
Academic Integrity
29m · 5 videos
Jackie's profile picture
Jackie Jones
·

802 students helped

Academic Integrity
Analysis of 'Ozymandias' by Percy Bysshe Shelley
42m · 4 videos
Nina's profile picture
Nina Modak
·

2k students helped

Analysis of 'Ozymandias' by Percy Bysshe Shelley