Asked by FatimaHistory 🕌

What is the most effective method of answering source based questions in A-level History, especially when comparing two sources?

Profile picture

VERIFIED

Verified tutor tick

Abubakr Karimabadi

Lawyer, Hafidh, Teacher

You have to analyse the purpose of the source, the context of the source, the author’s/publication’s background and find information from both sources which create debate. Question: Did the British give India independence or was it forced to? If we have a source written by a British author regarding the British Empire soon after the Second World War, one can assume the purpose of the source is to view the Empire’s impact positively. You will then need to find quotes in the source to support this claim. The second source may be written by an Indian historian writing about the Raj. We can assume it will be in favour of the latter part of the question and we can find quotes to support this claim. You will use each quote to make a point which will then be supported by secondary knowledge - what you know outside the sources. So you can find historical evidence where the British weren’t forced to give independence to support the first source and find evidence were they were forced to support the second source. You should always refer back to the question or you will veer off topic. At the end, you must reach a judgement. With respect to the question I’ve referred to here, I’d conclude by saying it was actually the Second World War which forced them to give up India as the British no longer had the means to maintain its empire. So in a way, they gave it to the Indians. If you continually refer to the source material and dissect any quote you use whilst showing off relevant historical knowledge to support your points and reach a conclusion on the question posed, you will receive high marks. Just practise and you’ll get the hang of it. Good luck!

Abubakr also answered

Asked in History 🕌

ASKED BY IVANNA

HISTORY 🕌

In the book things Fall Apart by China’s Achebe how was Okonkwo wrong in participating in the killing of Ikemefuna?

In “Things Fall Apart” by Chinua Achebe, Okonkwo is told through Ogbuefi Ezeudu that the Oracle has decreed that Ikemefuna be killed. Ezeudu also ca...

ASKED BY SELINA

HISTORY 🕌

Why was Kristalnacht so significant?

Kristallnacht was the ‘Night of Broken Glass’ as Nazi party paramilitary forces and civilians destroyed Jewish businesses and synagogues in November...

ASKED BY RICHARD

HISTORY 🕌

In the early 1900s, what did it mean for cities to be "dry"?

The sale and consumption of alchohol was prohibited.

ASKED BY SARAH

HISTORY 🕌

What were some of Deng Xiaoping's economic reforms?

Deng Xiaoping broadly introduced market elements to the Chinese economy. He was particularly inspired by the economic model used in Singapore. More ...

ASKED BY TIM

HISTORY 🕌

Why did most of the combat on the Western Front in World War I take place in a relatively small area?

Hey Tim, Interesting this is actually a bit of a myth! World war 1 saw combat across the world with battles in Asia, Africa, Northern Italy, Russia ...

ASKED BY MAX

HISTORY 🕌

What action on November 11, 1918, brought World War I to an end?

An armistice negotiated between the Allied Powers and Germany. This was in the effect a ceasefire between the two sides - the conflict didn’t formal...

ASKED BY JOE

HISTORY 🕌

What was the first country to be founded?

San Marino a microstate within a state surrounded by Italy was founded in 301 AD. It founded originally as a monastery and sits on top of Monte Teti...

ASKED BY ABIGAIL

HISTORY 🕌

What are the similarities between the American Revolution and Vietnam war?

Hello Abigail, To start with both wars involved one side trying to use standard war strategies while the other side used the landscape and environme...

ASKED BY ELIZABETH

HISTORY 🕌

How did oliver feel at the Sowerberrys house (from the book oliver twist )?

Oliver is taken in by Mr Sowerberry who is a likeable man. Having moved out of the workhouse, this was sure to be a relief for Oliver. However, Mrs ...

ASKED BY ANNIE

HISTORY 🕌

What was SILENT CINEMA? Why was the term somewhat misleading?

It was a genre of film that had no audible dialogue and the term can be seen as misleading because a lot of the time, the films would not actually b...

Find me a tutor

We take your privacy seriously. View our policy.