Asked by FatimaHistory 🕌

What is the most effective method of answering source based questions in A-level History, especially when comparing two sources?

Profile picture

VERIFIED

Verified tutor tick

Abubakr Karimabadi

Lawyer, Hafidh, Teacher

You have to analyse the purpose of the source, the context of the source, the author’s/publication’s background and find information from both sources which create debate. Question: Did the British give India independence or was it forced to? If we have a source written by a British author regarding the British Empire soon after the Second World War, one can assume the purpose of the source is to view the Empire’s impact positively. You will then need to find quotes in the source to support this claim. The second source may be written by an Indian historian writing about the Raj. We can assume it will be in favour of the latter part of the question and we can find quotes to support this claim. You will use each quote to make a point which will then be supported by secondary knowledge - what you know outside the sources. So you can find historical evidence where the British weren’t forced to give independence to support the first source and find evidence were they were forced to support the second source. You should always refer back to the question or you will veer off topic. At the end, you must reach a judgement. With respect to the question I’ve referred to here, I’d conclude by saying it was actually the Second World War which forced them to give up India as the British no longer had the means to maintain its empire. So in a way, they gave it to the Indians. If you continually refer to the source material and dissect any quote you use whilst showing off relevant historical knowledge to support your points and reach a conclusion on the question posed, you will receive high marks. Just practise and you’ll get the hang of it. Good luck!

Abubakr also answered

Asked in History 🕌

ASKED BY GAIA

HISTORY 🕌

How can I learn history better?

I would really recommend reading, be that textbooks or autobiographies. You can watch historical movies, but remember they may not be entirely accur...

ASKED BY LAIBA

HISTORY 🕌

How to revise for History?

Try to write things as many times as you can manage. This is the best way to learn.

ASKED BY JEREMY

HISTORY 🕌

Who started work war 1?

The simplest answer is that the immediate cause was the assassination of Franz Ferdinand, the archduke of Austria-Hungary. His death at the hands of...

ASKED BY JENIFFER

HISTORY 🕌

Why did the Soviet Union join the Allies?

The Soviet Union joined the Allies because she was invaded by German Nazi's.

ASKED BY MAISIE

HISTORY 🕌

When was Henry the 8th born?

28th June 1491 😀

ASKED BY ZUNAIRA

HISTORY 🕌

Who made the shards?

It has been designed by the Italian architect Renzo Pian.

ASKED BY MOLLIE

HISTORY 🕌

Who was Henry VIII 4th wife?

His fourth wife, chronologically, was Anne of Cleves. She was fortunate enough to outlive all of the other wives....

ASKED BY KACEY

HISTORY 🕌

What year did Oliver Cromwell die?

He died aged 59 on Friday 3 September 1658.

ASKED BY ELISE

HISTORY 🕌

Can anyone help with a level history coursework? Doing it on appeasement by the British government from 1919-1939?

Hi Elise This is something I’d be able to help with - this was an area of specialism of mine during my degree. Michael ...

ASKED BY ANNIE

HISTORY 🕌

Who was Churchill?

Churchill was a Conservative MP who served as Prime Minister of the UK from 1940-1945 and again from 1951-1955. He is most famous for guiding Britai...

Find me a tutor

We take your privacy seriously. View our policy.